Competitor Comparison
If you're evaluating illumend or looking for an illumend alternative, here's the operating difference that matters most: illumend, formerly myCOI, rebuilt their platform around Lumie, an AI engine that makes every compliance decision for you, automatically.
PINS automates what you want automated, from contract extraction, insurance review, and automated reminders, and keeps a person in the loop everywhere you want one.
You decide where that line sits, instead of illumend deciding for you.
Quick comparison
These are not two versions of the same approach. illumend requires Lumie AI to make compliance decisions for you. PINS gives you the option on what AI does versus what your team controls.
Best for: Teams that want to automate what makes sense, and keep a person in the loop everywhere else.
Best for: Teams that want to step back from COI review and their vendors or subcontractors entirely.
Third-party proof
Review sites point to exactly the tradeoff of a fully automated model: when the AI gets it wrong, no one catches it before the customer does.
It’s inaccurate, expensive, and overall very poor. It feels unprofessional and unfinished, and the AI simply does its job badly despite the high cost.
PINS lets you keeps a person in the loop before a status is set, so a misclassification gets caught by your team, not discovered by a vendor complaint after the fact.
Deep comparison
AI reviews submissions and returns findings with evidence. Your team sets every compliance status.
Lumie AI reviews submissions and sets compliance status automatically. No human approval step.
You choose what's automated versusd what requires your team's sign-off.
AI autonomy is set by the platform. No published configurability options.
Allows for every approval, rejection, waiver, and exception to go through your team before a status is set.
No human review step. Lumie sets compliance status automatically.
Every decision is logged under the team member who made it. Approvals, rejections, waivers, and exceptions are all documented.
Decisions are made by the AI. Human-attributed compliance decision history is limited.
Your team can control exceptions and waivers. Context and reasoning stay inside your process.
AI handles exceptions. Resolution of an incorrect AI classification depends on illumend's support process.
No login required. Vendors upload through a secure link. If AI findings need a second look, your team reviews before the vendor is told anything is wrong.
Vendors get immediate AI feedback on upload. If that analysis is wrong, the vendor sees an incorrect deficiency notice directly, and can only resolve it through illumend's AI chat interface, not a person on your team.
Transparent, predictable pricing.
3 to 5 times the cost of PINS.
Established platform with an active customer base in construction and public agencies.
Rebuilt and relaunched in 2026 under the illumend brand. Limited track record under the current platform.
Need help deciding?
The core difference is control over who makes the compliance decision. illumend uses Lumie AI to review COI submissions and set compliance status automatically. No human sign-off is required. PINS uses AI to handle the busywork, contract extraction, insurance review, and reminders, and returns findings so your team can approve, reject, waive, or escalate. Every compliance decision is made by a person on your team, not by the software.
Yes. illumend is built around Lumie, an AI engine designed to handle COI compliance review without requiring human sign-off. The system reviews submissions and sets compliance status based on the AI's assessment. PINS takes a different approach. AI handles contract extraction, insurance review, and reminders automatically, but your team sets every compliance status. Nothing is approved without a person reviewing the AI's findings first.
illumend has not published configurability options for Lumie's decision-making. The platform appears to operate as an all-or-nothing model. PINS lets you choose what's automated, contract extraction, insurance review, reminders, and keeps compliance status decisions with your team. You control where automation runs, not just whether it exists.
illumend is the rebranded version of myCOI, relaunched in 2026 with a rebuilt platform centered on Lumie AI. These are meaningfully different products. myCOI operated as a managed service: their team reviewed COI submissions on behalf of customers. illumend replaced that model with fully automated AI review. If you evaluated myCOI and are now evaluating illumend, you are evaluating a different operating model under the same parent company. For a comparison focused specifically on the myCOI managed service model, see PINS vs myCOI.
illumend may appeal to teams that want to remove themselves from day-to-day COI review entirely and are comfortable with AI setting compliance status on their behalf. PINS is a better fit for teams that want AI to handle the routine work while keeping approval authority with their own staff. If your team needs to make judgment calls on exceptions, waivers, and non-standard coverage situations, the PINS model is built for that. If you prefer full automation without a human review step, illumend is built for that instead.
Stop Reviewing.
Start Approving.
